Mamelodi Sundowns have spoken out following explosive claims from Lucas Ribeiro Costa. He accused the club of blocking his overseas transfer. The reigning PSL Player of the Season alleges Masandawana deliberately inflated his asking price. This made it impossible for European and Middle Eastern suitors to seal a deal.
The 26-year-old Brazilian enjoyed a remarkable 2024/25 campaign. He scooped four major PSL awards and dazzled at the FIFA Club World Cup in the United States. There, he earned the Goal of the Tournament. His performances inevitably caught global attention. However, his three-year contract with Sundowns remains the central stumbling block.
A Legal Fight on the Horizon
Ribeiro has already terminated his deal and declared he has “just cause” to take his case to the FIFA Football Tribunal. His lawyer, Jean-Louis Dupont – famed for successfully representing French midfielder Lassana Diarra in a similar contractual dispute – insists Sundowns have acted unfairly.
According to Dupont, Qatar SC tabled an offer “well above Ribeiro’s valuation.” Yet Sundowns kept raising the price in what he described as an “unreasonable” manner. He argued the club’s handling of negotiations failed to consider Ribeiro’s personal and professional needs. This included his desire for stability for his young family.
“This is not just about money,” Dupont stressed. “It is about respecting a player’s career path and allowing him the opportunity to grow.” His comments suggest a potential drawn-out legal battle, with Ribeiro prepared to escalate matters if FIFA declines to intervene.
Mamelodi Sundowns Reiterate Commitment
In response, Sundowns released a lengthy statement underscoring their commitment to player growth and fair negotiations. The club highlighted its significant investments in youth development. They also emphasized the recruitment of top talent from South Africa, Africa, and South America.
“Mamelodi Sundowns’ success is based on its deep commitment to the development, growth and financial sustainability of the club’s players,” the statement read. “It has always been the policy of Mamelodi Sundowns to engage and negotiate with football clubs in Africa and worldwide that are interested in acquiring the services of our players. The objective has always been to advance the interests of both the player and the club in a fair and just manner.”
The Brazilians also acknowledged they had received enquiries from several prominent teams. This happened particularly after their Club World Cup exploits. They confirmed discussions are ongoing. They emphasised that negotiations are never designed to obstruct players. Instead, they aim to safeguard the long-term stability of both the club and its squad members.
Balancing Player Ambition and Club Interests
The Sundowns statement leans heavily on the idea of fairness and balance. The Tshwane side argue that while they recognise players’ ambitions, they also have a responsibility to protect their investments and ensure stability. With Ribeiro contracted until 2028, Sundowns are within their rights to demand appropriate compensation, especially considering the player’s rising profile.
Club insiders also suggest that their policy of holding firm on transfer fees is designed to ensure that South African talent is not undervalued in international markets. Sundowns believe they have a duty not only to their players but also to the reputation of the domestic league.
Wider Implications for South African Football
The fallout with Ribeiro highlights a growing tension in the local game. More players, including Khuliso Mudau and Thapelo Maseko, are believed to be frustrated by blocked overseas opportunities. If Ribeiro succeeds in his challenge, it could set a legal precedent that reshapes how PSL clubs negotiate player exits.
For now, Sundowns remain focused on their on-field campaign. With Ribeiro absent from their opening matches, the club must strike a balance between competing for titles and managing one of the most high-profile disputes in their history.
A Defining Moment for Masandawana
What lies ahead may well define Sundowns’ transfer policy for years to come. Whether Ribeiro finds his way to Europe or the Middle East, or Sundowns successfully defend their stance, this case has already sparked a conversation. It highlights how South African clubs balance ambition with loyalty, and business with fairness.
Related article: Lucas Ribeiro Alleges Sundowns Sabotaged His Career with Sky-High Transfer Fee
