Kaizer Chiefs vs Orlando Pirates: Who Won the Summer Transfer Market Battle?

The Transfer Market has seen numerous departures and signings, and both Kaizer Chiefs and Orlando Pirates have been busy reshaping their squads ahead of the new campaign. With the 22 September transfer deadline approaching, many fans are asking: who has emerged as the winner in this summer’s transfer market?

Let’s break down the key moves and assess which club has made the most significant impact.

Orlando Pirates: A Major Overhaul with Fresh Faces

Orlando Pirates have made the boldest moves in the transfer market, with a significant overhaul of their squad. The club has released 15 players, including key figures such as:

• Mohau Nkota (Al-Ettifaq, Saudi Arabia)
• Monnapule Saleng (loan to Orbit College)
• Zakhele Lepasa
• Katlego Otladisa
• Paseka Mako (Kaizer Chiefs)
• Thabiso Monyane (Kaizer Chiefs)
• Yanga Madiba
• Azola Tshobeni
• Ndabayithethwa Ndlondlo
• Abdoulaye S Makiro
• Miguel Timm
• Thuso Moleleki
• Siphelo Baloni
• Goodman Mosele
• Karim Kimvuidi

These exits signal a shift in the club’s philosophy and approach to the upcoming season.

In terms of new arrivals, Pirates have signed 12 fresh faces, including:

• Sipho Mbule (Mamelodi Sundowns): A dynamic midfielder who is expected to add creativity and control to the middle of the park.
• Oswin Appollis (Polokwane City): A pacey winger who can provide goals and assist in wide areas.
• Tshepho Mashiloane: A versatile full-back who adds defensive stability.
• Tshepang Moremi: A promising winger
• Nkosikhona Ndaba: A promising left-back with room for development.
• Lebone Seema (TS Galaxy): A central defender who has impressed in pre-season.
• Sinoxolo Kwayiba: Highly regarded as a number 10.
• Yanele Mbuthuma: A promising striker with potential to be a top-tier PSL talent.
• Kamogelo Sebelebele (TS Galaxy): Arguably the best signing of the window.
• Sihle Nduli: Known for his intelligence at the base of midfield.
• Masindi Nemtajela: A potential future successor to Nduli, signed from Marumo Gallants for the engine room.
• Abdoulaye Mariko: Add creativity and depth to the midfield.

This influx of new signings is aimed at reinvigorating the squad and addressing weak areas, particularly in attack and defence.

Kaizer Chiefs: Strategic Signings to Strengthen the Squad

Kaizer Chiefs have also been active in the transfer market, signing 11 players to reinforce their squad. The notable signings include:

• Siphesihle Ndlovu (SuperSport United): A seasoned midfielder with over 200 PSL appearances, Ndlovu brings stability and creativity to the Chiefs midfield.
• Nkanyiso Shinga: A solid left-back to boost the club’s defensive options.
• Flavio Silva: A striker expected to add competition up front.
• Ethan Chislett: A creative attacking midfielder with flair and vision.
• Paseka Mako (Orlando Pirates): A full-back from Pirates to bolster Chiefs’ defensive options.
• Thabiso Monyane (Orlando Pirates): Another full-back from Pirates to add depth to Chiefs’ defence.
• Asanele Velebayi (Cape Town Spurs): A young attacking talent who can make an immediate impact.
• Luke Baartman (Cape Town Spurs): A forward with plenty of promise.
• Etiosa Ighodaro: A striker expected to add strength and depth to the attack.
• Lebohang Maboe (Mamelodi Sundowns): A versatile forward who can contribute both creatively and in front of goal.
• Khanyisa Mayo: Another exciting addition to Chiefs’ forward line.

Departures from Chiefs include:

• Sabelo Radebe, Bongani Sam, Ranga Chivaviro, Edmilson Dove, Mduduzi Mdantsane, Yusuf Maart, Edson Castillo, and Tebogo Potsane: All have left the club, making room for the new signings.

Who Won the Summer Transfer Market Battle?

While both clubs have made notable signings, Orlando Pirates have arguably won the summer transfer market battle. Their decision to overhaul the squad with 12 new signings, including some high-profile additions like Sipho Mbule and Oswin Appollis, puts them in a stronger position to compete for top honours. The fresh faces, especially in key areas like midfield and attack, should provide Pirates with the depth and creativity needed for a strong season.

On the other hand, Kaizer Chiefs have made fewer but more targeted moves, bringing in experienced players like Siphesihle Ndlovu and talented players such as Flavio Silva and Ethan Chislett. While their signings are solid, they have not made as many dramatic changes as Pirates.

Check also: Mbekezeli Mbokazi Shines as Bafana Bafana’s Next Star Poised for Europe

Both Kaizer Chiefs and Orlando Pirates have made significant moves in the transfer market, but Orlando Pirates’ bold squad overhaul and influx of quality players position them as the winners of this summer’s transfer battle. The club’s strengthened attack and defence, along with the addition of experienced and talented players, should make them serious contenders for the upcoming season.

What do you think of the changes at both clubs? Do you believe Pirates have done enough to top Chiefs in the upcoming season? Let us know in the comments!